
Toxic Toys
By Kristin A. Smith
Published in Curve Magazine
You know what you like. You’ve spent years perfecting it. You know how to cinch it, stuff it and strap it on. You know what speed you want and what length you need. You know how to ask about it in the store and ask for it in bed. You are a sex toy connoisseur and you may know what feels good, but do you know if it IS good?
Cheaply made sex toys are full of harmful chemicals. The most ubiquitous of these chemicals are phthalates (pronounced THA-lates), which are added to otherwise hard PVC toys to make them flexible enough for your enjoyment. Manufacturers add a chemical cocktail of phthalates to destabilize the molecules and give the toy that soft, realistic feel.
It’s not just adult toys that contain phthalates; some children’s toys also contain the chemicals. But children’s toys are becoming government regulated. There is no currently regulation for adult toys.
“In some ways that’s good,” says Jessica Giordani, founder of The Coalition Against Toxic Toys (CATT) and owner of Smitten Kitten, a sex shop in Minneapolis. “We don’t want the government in our sex lives…but it means we have to be smarter consumers.”
Being a smarter consumer means making connections. No study has been conducted on the danger of phthalates in sex toys, but studies have been done on phthalates in children’s toys; the results show a link between phthalates and liver and hormonal damage. The European Union and the state of California have now banned the chemicals in children’s toys. Giordani says we need to ask ourselves, “If it’s dangerous for my kid in a pacifier, might it also be dangerous for me in a butt plug?”
Phthalates aren’t just used in butt plugs; they’re used in a lot of toys— a lot of your favorite toys, like the “Rabbit Habit,” with its little pearls of joy. Babeland founder Clair

e Cavanah says that while Rabbit Habit was one of their best selling toys, they have taken it off the market and replaced it with a new phthalate-free version of the toy.
Giordani and Smitten Kitten partner Jennifer Pritchett went further than just pulling phthalate-infected toys from their shelves. With what they describe as “an information blackout” about the dangers of chemicals in sex toys, Giordani and Pritchett took matters into their own hands.
The CATT founders brought some of the most scrupulous toys to a chemist for testing. Among the chosen toys—the newly popular Cyberskin products. The women were surprised to learn that the product contained no phthalates, but did contain “industrial grade mineral oil,” a compound that Giordani says is “essentially kerosene.”
Giordani says that unless you are a chemist yourself or go to have your toys tested, there’s no way to know the chemical makeup of your toys. But there are ways to tell if your toys contain phthalates. “Trust your nose,” says Giordani. “The new car smell, those are phthalates.” She adds that if the toy melts when boiled, it probably contains phthalates as well.
Many companies, even boutiques, still sell phthalate-infected toys. Some stores urge you to use a condom with anything that may contain dangerous chemicals, but Giordani says there is no proof that a condom will keep you safe from toxins. “If there was,” she says, “we’d all be walking around covered in giant condoms.” She adds that good sex shops should have floor models that you can feel and smell before you buy.
So why are these toxic toys still on the market? Denise Corona, owner of Vixen Creations, a toxic free toy manufacturer in San Francisco says, “it’s all about the profit margin—with a lack of oversight and cheap overseas labor, sex toys are affordable, but not always safe.”
Even with all the dangerous toys on the market, there are still some that are guaranteed harmless—Glass, surgical steel and medical grade silicone are sure to tickle your fancy while keeping you safe.
All images from
smittenkittenonline.com